Linda's Literary Home

Category: Emily Dickinson

  • Emily Dickinson’s “I cannot dance upon my Toes”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “I cannot dance upon my Toes”

    Famously, the poet Emily Dickinson lived a reclusive life.  She protected her privacy.  In her poetry canon, she often crafted little poetic dramas exploring and exposing the great joy her solitude afforded her. This poem is one of those little dramas.

    Introduction with Text of “I cannot dance upon my Toes”

    Emily Dickinson’s “I cannot dance upon my Toes” offers five stanzas, setting forth the poet’s famous slant rimes and non-traditional rhythms. The speaker is celebrating, with special emphasis, her personal experiences of “Glee.”

    She knows that her readers/listeners will readily perceive her comparison to great performances in dance, theater, and opera.  While her speaker does not link her joyous ecstasy to any particular public performances, she experiences great ecstatic bliss which she deems similar to the feelings heralded by such artistic displays.

    I cannot dance upon my Toes

    I cannot dance upon my Toes –
    No Man instructed me –
    But oftentimes, among my mind,
    A Glee possesseth me,

    That had I Ballet knowledge –
    Would put itself abroad
    In Pirouette to blanch a Troupe –
    Or lay a Prima, mad,

    And though I had no Gown of Gauze –
    No Ringlet, to my Hair,
    Nor hopped to Audiences – like Birds,
    One Claw upon the Air,

    Nor tossed my shape in Eider Balls,
    Nor rolled on wheels of snow
    Till I was out of sight, in sound,
    The House encore me so –

    Nor any know I know the Art
    I mention – easy –Here –
    Nor any Placard boast me –
    It’s full as Opera –

    Commentary on “I cannot dance upon my Toes”

    In Emily Dickinson’s “I cannot dance upon my Toes,” the speaker is creating a colorful poetic drama that examines the amazing joy afforded her through her engagement with solitude.

    First Quatrain:  The Joy of Dancing

    I cannot dance upon my Toes –
    No Man instructed me –
    But oftentimes, among my mind,
    A Glee possesseth me,

    The speaker asserts that she does not have the proficiency to dance as a ballerina would, because she has not received the necessary training and lessons that such dancers need to undergo. However, there are times during which she has the ability to experience indescribable joy of her soul.  She suggests that such joy may be similar to that experienced through ballet.

    The ability to dance upon one’s the toes remains a physical prowess, and very few individuals ever have the ability to reach such a lofty achievement.  Because such ability and talent remain so rare, the speaker assumes that those who have the talent to render such performances must then experience “Glee.”

    Second Quatrain:  Skill That Remains Amazing

    That had I Ballet knowledge –
    Would put itself abroad
    In Pirouette to blanch a Troupe –
    Or lay a Prima, mad,

    The speaker then reports that if she ever had the special talent and physical agility to dance upon her toes, she would experience a fantastic level of “Glee.”  The feeling would allow her to beam her talent as does the best of artists in the art of the ballet.

    She is sure that her amazing skill would put the prima ballerina to shame causing that dancer to become maddened.  The entire company of the ballet would become astonished by her amazing skill.

    The speaker’s exaggeration places emphasize upon her belief that her soul qualities alone are responsible for her actual talent, and she wishes to pay homage to the Divine Essence which bestows on her such abilities. 

    Third Quatrain:  No Fancy Outerwear

    And though I had no Gown of Gauze –
    No Ringlet, to my Hair,
    Nor hopped to Audiences –like Birds,
    One Claw upon the Air,

    In the third quatrain, the speaker reveals that she does not own gowns and gauze, as the famously public celebrity would possess.  She also does not have the ability to sport other fancy clothing as theatrical talent may do.  She also cannot have her hair styled into decorous fashion.  No make-up artists ever visit her to ply their wares. She will wear no ringlets in her hair.

    Because the speaker does not engage in the art of the ballet, she does not have the ability to fully comprehend that specialized art form.  She freely admits that she has never engaged and will never experience the feelings that ballet dancers do as they cavort and prance upon the stage “like Birds” with “One Claw upon the Air.”

    The speaker seems to express a modicum of disdain in describing the ballerinas as birds hopping across as stage with their hands in the air resembling the claw of a bird.  That fascinating image elevates the description as it so colorfully fits the event.

    Fourth Quatrain:  Keeping Life Simple

    Nor tossed my shape in Eider Balls,
    Nor rolled on wheels of snow
    Till I was out of sight, in sound,
    The House encore me so –

    The speaker then offers further images that reveal experiences which she has never had and likely never will experience.  For example, she has never “tossed” her body in “Eider Balls.”  Instead of the fancy, intricate costumes which ballerinas and opera singers wear, this speaker dresses herself in simple clothing. 

    She has never finished a performance by dancing out of sight of the audience.  She has never been called back to the stage by a ardent group of fans as they continue to applaud, prompting her to return to give them an enthusiastic “encore.”

    Fifth Quatrain:  Heavenly Rewards

    Nor any know I know the Art
    I mention –easy –Here –
    Nor any Placard boast me –
    It’s full as Opera –

    This speaker is demonstrating that she resides and thrives far outside of the milieu of ballet dancers.  She suspects that no one with whom she is acquainted would even have an inkling that she has ever become aware that such an art exists. 

    Through intuition, this speaker can comprehend that the value of her work and her ultimate worth are equal to –if, in fact, they do not overtake in value –that of the performances that have received so many accolades of praise.  

    She is convinced that her accolades remain on a mystical level of being.  Therefore, she can dance upon her toes –if only metaphorically and mystically –through her God-given talents reserved especially for her.

    Through this speaker, the poet has paid tribute to her poetic talent and even, at least in her own mind, has elevated her own talent.  In effect, she is averring that she is quite content to be unknown poet.  

    Even having the ability to be a celebrated prima ballerina cannot complete with the joy she experiences through her poetry creation.  Her garden of verse offers her her own stage for performance that makes it possible for her to live a complete life.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose”

    The speaker in Dickinson’s poem “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose” is dramatizing what she knows about the sunrise but then hazards only a dramatic guess about sunset. Her choice for the target of her knowledge transforms the simple of act sunrise into a symbol.

    Introduction with Text of “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose”

    Emily Dickinson’s poem “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose” consists of sixteen lines, featuring her signature slant rimes and a generous sprinkling of dashes. The poem is written as one piece without divisions by stanzas but sections itself topically into four movements.

    The first two movements describe how the sun came up on the particular morning of the speaker’s choosing, while in the second two movements, the speaker is simply dramatizing her suggestion for why she cannot explain how the sun set.

    I’ll tell you how the Sun rose

    I’ll tell you how the Sun rose –
    A Ribbon at a time –
    The Steeples swam in Amethyst –
    The news, like Squirrels, ran –
    The Hills untied their Bonnets –
    The Bobolinks – begun –
    Then I said softly to myself –
    “That must have been the Sun”!
    But how he set – I know not –
    There seemed a purple stile
    That little Yellow boys and girls
    Were climbing all the while –
    Till when they reached the other side,
    A Dominie in Gray –
    Put gently up the evening Bars –
    And led the flock away –

    Commentary on “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose”

    Emily Dickinson’s “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose” is dramatizing what the speaker knows about the sunrise but then hazards only a dramatic guess about sunset.  Interestingly, she is suggesting that she can observe the sunrise but not the sunset.

    First Movement:   Explaining the Unexplainable 

    I’ll tell you how the Sun rose –
    A Ribbon at a time –
    The Steeples swam in Amethyst –
    The news, like Squirrels, ran –

    The speaker announces that she will be explaining to her listeners, “how the Sun rose.”  She then through the employment of metaphor likens the sun’s rays to ribbons that are released a single ribbon at a time.  The colorful sun ribbons of rays are leisurely released, and they hover the ocean to a place where the steeples of churches appear to “sw[i]m in Amethyst.” 

    The sun’s fire then looms upon the blackness, immediately reverting to blue as it takes on a brightness, fully glowing because of the light that the sun has released.   The luminescence of the sun spreads with great haste; thus the speaker compares its speed to the scampering of squirrels, as she calls the event “news.”

    Second Movement:  The Ordinary Made Extraordinary

    The Hills untied their Bonnets –
    The Bobolinks – begun –
    Then I said softly to myself –
    “That must have been the Sun”!

    The speaker now asserts that the hills removed their “Bonnets,” and the birds knowns as “Bobolinks” commenced their singing.  The metaphoric personification of hills with bonnets suggests that all of nature is coming alive again, and the speaker knows this because she sees many colors that may be detected in the faraway hills.  Birds have awakened, and they have begun their many layered chirping.

    The speaker’s reaction is such that it would make it seem she is seeing this event for the first time.  She muses and quotes herself breathlessly, for example, as she exclaims,”‘That must have been the Sun’!”  The speaker is creating her little drama using ordinary items from her environment which she makes extraordinary in her reporting.

    Third Movement:  A Forceful Drama

    But how he set – I know not –
    There seemed a purple stile
    That little Yellow boys and girls
    Were climbing all the while –

    The speaker then envisions her situation to be nearer to sunrise than to sunset.  This idea, of course, is merely fictional, but it offers her the ability to create her drama of how the sun rises.  She knows she cannot explain scientifically such an event, but she can forcefully and dramatically imagine it.

    So in order to explain sunset, she imagines she can see a set of steps that appear purple in color from a distance.  Little Chinese children are climbing on those steps.   Those children are likely just going home from a day of school or tending sheep.

    Fourth Movement:  The Cover of Darkness

    Till when they reached the other side,
    A Dominie in Gray –
    Put gently up the evening Bars –
    And led the flock away –

    The children have climbed to the other side of the stile, an event that signals the sun’s lowest point just as it then vanishes from sight.  A shepherd or perhaps even a churchman secures the gate then leads the flock of sheep or perhaps children away from that area.

    Because darkness is now hovering thick, the speaker cannot offer any images for what may be happening next.  The speaker’s lack of knowledge about sunset is reflected in her word choices which are much less certain than her drama about how the sun rises.  By suggesting that she can tell you all about how the sun rose but not so much about how it set implies the speaker prefers sunrise to sunset.

    The Symbolism of Sunrise

    In Emily Dickinson’s “I’ll tell you how the Sun rose,” sunrise becomes symbolic of life-enhancing positivity: the beginning of the day offers opportunities for living and creating.  Sunset, on the other hand, simply offers the opportunity for sleep.

    The curious active mind is always hankering for more positive opportunities for acting out its desires, for securing a stage for creativity, and for living its need for motion.  That stage is daylight, after the sun rises and throws its life-giving rays upon land and its inhabitants.  

  • Emily Dickinson’s “There’s a certain Slant of light”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “There’s a certain Slant of light”

    Dickinson closely observed and investigated her surroundings; she also keenly examined her own feelings then dramatized those feelings in poems.  In “There’s a certain Slant of light,” her speaker is infusing melancholy into her perception of light streaming through a window on a winter afternoon.

    Introduction with Text of “There’s a certain Slant of light”

    Emily Dickinson developed the habit of closely observing as she investigated her surroundings.  The poet then keenly examined and mused upon her own feelings, finally dramatizing those feelings in poems.

    The poet created this speaker in “There’s a certain Slant of light” to reveal a mood of slight melancholy as she muses on a shaft of light streaming in through her window on a winter afternoon.  

    That streaming light through the window seems to tip and tilt, that is, “slant,” in a way that causes the speaker to undergo that sense of melancholy, which is no ordinary gloom but brings with it a spiritual aspect. 

    The speaker creates a little drama based on her intense feeling of spiritual intuition which has been motivated by a simple “Slant of light” streaming in through the window on a cold, winter afternoon.

    There’s a certain Slant of light

    There’s a certain Slant of light,
    Winter Afternoons –
    That oppresses, like the Heft
    Of Cathedral Tunes –

    Heavenly Hurt, it gives us –
    We can find no scar,
    But internal difference,
    Where the Meanings, are –

    None may teach it – Any –
    ‘Tis the Seal Despair –
    An imperial affliction
    Sent us of the air –

    When it comes, the Landscape listens –
    Shadows – hold their breath –
    When it goes, ’tis like the Distance
    On the look of Death –

    Reading of “There’s a certain Slant of light” 

    Commentary on “There’s a certain Slant of light”

    A simple viewing of a shaft of light streaming into the room on a winter day engenders in this speaker a melancholy prompting this little drama.  The spiritual experience thus is rendered in paradox—the ultimate literary device for communicating the ineffable.

    First Stanza:  The Oppression of Tilting Light

    There’s a certain Slant of light,
    Winter Afternoons –
    That oppresses, like the Heft
    Of Cathedral Tunes –

    The speaker begins the drama by asserting that on certain winter afternoons the light shining in through her window comes in at a “certain Slant” and that tilting light “oppresses” her in the way the heavy tones of sacred chants might do. Although light is weightless, to the speaker in this particular mood, it seems heavy enough to oppress her into melancholy.

    A paradox results from the speaker finding the “light” to be as heavy as church music.  Music experienced in church is meant to uplift, not weigh one down.  If something that is meant to uplift does the opposite, then one has to explore the reasons for such oppression.  Why would music that ordinarily produces a spiritual upliftment become an instrument of oppression—that is, something that is heavy?

    Second Stanza:  The Human Craving for Meaning

    Heavenly Hurt, it gives us –
    We can find no scar,
    But internal difference,
    Where the Meanings, are –

    The deeply inspiring sound of “Cathedral Tunes” brings the speaker to a place of “Heavenly Hurt.”  Again, she paradoxically describes her experience:  Heaven is a spiritual place where there is no hurt, no pain, no distress, no oppression—only bliss. 

    The speaker confirms as much as she avers that this “hurt” never results in a “scar.”  And it also leaves no physical mark such as scar because this melancholy is inside of the speaker; it is her soul that has engaged with this music, this light, that has caused this spiritual experience.

    The speaker employs the term, “Meaning”—all human beings on all levels of awareness crave meaning in their lives, and the speaker has become aware of the meaning of an inner life that is more important than the corporeal.  True meaning come from the soul not from the body that changes and dies, nor from the mind that knows nothing but change.

    Third Stanza:  Soul Meaning

    None may teach it – Any –
    ‘Tis the Seal Despair –
    An imperial affliction
    Sent us of the air –

    The speaker then affirms that one cannot be taught this kind of soul meaning. The mystical state of the desire for meaning comes on one unbidden, as casually as taking a breath. “Despair” of the material world often leads one to ask the question, is this all there is to life?

    But the individual becomes a seeker after she begins to entertain such questions.  Divine cravings may be prompted by any outward experience such as light tilting in through a window, but those cravings for spiritual reality can be satisfied only through soul-union, which is Divine Awareness.  The melancholy of spiritual desire is a first step to that Ultimate Awareness.

    Fourth Stanza:  The Nature of Reality

    When it comes, the Landscape listens –
    Shadows – hold their breath –
    When it goes, ’tis like the Distance
    On the look of Death – 

    After the strong spiritual desire for meaning, that is, comprehending the nature of Reality approaches the sensibility of the individual, that individual wished to cease the flux of all phenomena in order to listen—”be still and know that I am God” (KJV, Psalm 46:10).

    This speaker creates her drama by asserting that “Shadows  – hold their breath.”  Shadows holding their breath suggests a depth of quietness that is nearly unfathomable.  A miraculous awareness engulfs the speaker.

    The speaker has discovered that this “heavenly hurt,” this spiritual melancholy, transforms itself into the light of understanding.  Death loses its grip and meaning after such a level of awareness is achieved, no longer grasping the heart and mind of the individual.  

    After death has become merely a distant force, the spiritual aspirant sees more clearly all other forces that operate in her sphere.  The speaker has thus reached that inner Goal.  Death is beaten and given its place to Awareness. 

    The Science and Symbolism of Light

    That a simple “Slant of light” should engender a deep mystic state of awareness in this speaker is quite apt.  Regarding the nature of light, in his spiritual classic, Autobiography of a Yogi [1], Paramahansa Yogananda has explained that the material universe is composed of light.  Many modern discoveries have revealed to humanity that the cosmos is composed of various expressions of one power—light—guided by Divine Intelligence.

    Paramahansa Yogananda has also explained that only differing rates of vibration account for the differing forms that exist throughout the cosmos:

    Modern science has shown that everything in the universe is composed of energy (light), and that the apparent differentiation between solids, liquids, gases, sound, and light is merely a difference in their vibratory rates.

    Also in his autobiography, Paramahansa Yogananda has explained in detail the nature of light, comparing it to other “waves”:

    Among the trillion mysteries of the cosmos, the most phenomenal is light. Unlike sound waves, whose transmission requires air or other material media, light waves pass freely through the vacuum of interstellar space. Even the hypothetical ether, held as the interplanetary medium of light in the undulatory theory, may be discarded on the Einsteinian grounds that the geometrical properties of space render unnecessary a theory of ether. Under either hypothesis, light remains the most subtle, the freest from material dependence, of any natural manifestation.

    The individual who has achieved the realization that “the essence of creation is light” is thus capable of operating the law of miracles.  The term miracle simply applies to any phenomenon whose operation science [2] has yet to discover.  

    What the soul knows through intuition will always be running miles and years ahead of what physical science [3] knows because physical science can explore and examine only the created cosmos not the Creator of that cosmos.  The soul, however, being a spark of the Creator, knows all that the Creator knows—either in fact or in potential.

    Emily Dickinson’s employment of light in this poem thus results from her deep intuitive awareness that light is the building substance of the cosmos.  Therefore, “light” becomes a symbol for that intuition that would continue to guide the poet as she continued to create her  mystical, metaphysical, metaphorical “garden” of poetry.

    Sources

    [1]  Paramahansa Yogananda.  Autobiography of a Yogi.  Self-Realization Fellowship.  Accessed June 3, 2026.
    [2]  Ard Louis.  “Miracles and Science: The Long Shadow of David Hume.”  The BioLogos Foundation.  March 12, 2018.
    [3]  Lisa Zyga.  “Quantum Mysticism: Gone but Not Forgotten.” Phys.org.  June 8, 2009.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died”

    Emily Dickinson’s “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died” dramatizes the speaker’s act of dying, as well as Dickinson’s mystical vision, which corresponds to yogic philosophical and religious teachings.

    Introduction and Text of “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died”

    Emily Dickinson’s “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died” consists of four rimed quatrains with the rime scheme ABCB. Most of the rimes are slant rimes: Room-Storm, firm-room, be-fly. Sprinkled liberally with her signature dashes, the poem displays an appropriate breathless quality. 

    I heard a Fly buzz – when I died

    I heard a Fly buzz – when I died –
    The Stillness in the Room
    Was like the Stillness in the Air –
    Between the Heaves of Storm –

    The Eyes around – had wrung them dry –
    And Breaths were gathering firm
    For that last Onset – when the King
    Be witnessed – in the Room –

    I willed my Keepsakes – Signed away
    What portion of me be
    Assignable – and then it was
    There interposed a Fly –

    With Blue – uncertain stumbling Buzz –
    Between the light – and me –
    And then the Windows failed – and then
    I could not see to see –

    Commentary on  “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died “

    Emily Dickinson’s “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died” dramatizes the speaker’s act of dying.  Even though it is unlikely that the poet had studied any Eastern philosophy as Ralph Waldo Emerson had done, her mystical vision corresponds nearly perfectly to Eastern yogic philosophical and religious teachings.

    First Stanza:  Breathlessness upon Dying

    I heard a Fly buzz – when I died –
    The Stillness in the Room
    Was like the Stillness in the Air –
    Between the Heaves of Storm –

    In the first stanza, the speaker makes the odd assertion that as she was dying, she heard the sound of a fly.   The first instance of the breathlessness of the poem occurs immediately following the announcement, “I heard a Fly buzz.” Such a mundane statement if left unmodified! But the speaker then adds a real shocker, “when I died.” 

    Nothing could be more startling, nothing could be more Dickinsonian. The room at the time of her passing professed an eerie stillness, reminding the speaker of the quiet that settles briefly between the turbulences of a storm. The mention of the fly then hangs without further discussion until the last line of the third stanza. 

    Second Stanza:  Mourning the Passing

    The Eyes around – had wrung them dry –
    And Breaths were gathering firm
    For that last Onset – when the King
    Be witnessed – in the Room –

    The speaker then depicts the people who are beginning their mourning of her passing: her loved ones had cried until they could not cry any longer.   The mourners seemed to hold their breath, waiting for that moment when the soul of the loved one makes its final departure from the body: such a momentous occasion herald’s the Divine Belovèd emissary to be in attendance. 

    The King refers to God’s angel, who will appear to escort the soul from the physical to the astral plane. While the escaping soul will be cognizant of the angel, most of the mourners probably will not be, but they will intuit the presence or “that last Onset,” which prompts the breath to tighten.

    Third Stanza:  Last Will and Testament

    I willed my Keepsakes – Signed away
    What portion of me be
    Assignable – and then it was
    There interposed a Fly –

    The speaker asserts that she has completed her last will and testament, designating which “Keepsakes” should go and to whom; she has assigned to others everything that can be assigned.  Some time has obviously passed between making the will and the moment presently dramatized. 

    The immediate shift from something she must have accomplished earlier suggests the conflating power of the dying process, something like the old expression that one’s life passes before one’s sight at death. And then the “Fly” makes it appearance: “There interposed a Fly.” But she begins a new stanza to portray the importance of the “Fly.” 

    Fourth Stanza:  No Ordinary House Fly

    With Blue – uncertain stumbling Buzz –
    Between the light – and me –
    And then the Windows failed – and then
    I could not see to see –

    The significant final stanza reveals that the fly is not a literal household fly but is a metaphor for the sound of the soul leaving the body. The line “With Blue – uncertain stumbling Buzz” has taken the place of the term “fly.” 

    In nature, flies appear to be black not blue.  However, as the human soul is existing its physical encasement, it experiences the blue that makes up part of the spiritual eye with its outer golden circle which rims the blue inside of which is a pentagonal white star.  The soul must travel through this eye, often referred to as a tunnel by those who have experienced near-death episodes and returned to describe their experience.

    The sound of a bumble bee or “fly,” which is a buzzing sound, is emanated by the coccygeal chakra in the spine.  As the soul journeys up the spine, it begins at the buzz chakra.  In very advanced yogis, the “buzz” sound might be described as the “om” sound.

    With the “Buzz” sound emanating from the departing soul beginning its journey from the coccygeal center, the physical eyesight begins to fail–”then the Windows failed / and then / I could not see to see.”   The speaker’s unusual claim “I could not see to see” underscores the fact that her light of vision is fading, and the final dash represents its total departure. 

    Evidence of Mystical Ability

    Although it is highly unlikely that Emily Dickinson had studied any yogic philosophy or techniques, her accurate descriptions of the process of death as well as her descriptions of experiences after death provide evidence that the poet possessed advanced mystical insight.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination”

    Emily Dickinson’s speaker in “Color – Caste – Denomination” is demonstrating a profound truth about the flaws in human classifications that still today lead to ill-will and even violence toward members of different racial, social class, and religion groups.

    Human Classifications:  Two Views

    Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination” and Arna Bontemps’ “God Give to Men” take as their theme the issue of the classifications that humanity has through the centuries imposed upon itself.  

    While there are many ways that human beings identity themselves, three common ones are race, class (social status), and religion; thus, Dickinson has labeled the classes “color” (race), “caste” (class, social status), and “denomination” (religion).

    Arna Bontemps in his race conscious piece “God Give to Men” has concentrated primarily on the classification of color (race).  He refers to the skin color for two of the classes—”yellow” and “black”—but then uses the eye color “blue” for the third class.  The poets Emily Dickinson and Arna Bontemps have handled the issue of human classification in two quite disparate ways:  

    (1) Dickinson’s drama serves to unite all human classes, as her speaker insists that each human being is a soul without any of the outward classifications with which humanity has burdened itself.

    (2) Bontemps’ speaker remains squarely focused on the issues that he finds repugnant or venal in each color class, not his own.  As his speaker asks God to give certain gifts to men, he reveals his animosity toward two of his designated classes.  The third class receives rather short shrift in an ironic attempt at humility.

    Dickinson’s ultimate truth is based on the individuality of each human being, while Bontemps relies heavily on racial stereotypes [1], which  serve only to divide, not unify, for not all members of any so-called classification represent the concocted stereotype that attempts to define and describe that classification.

    Text of Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination”

    The speaker in Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination” demonstrates a profound understanding regarding the futility of human classifications [2]  based on race, class, religion, and sex.

    The theme of the Dickinson poem is likely influenced by Galatians 3: 28: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus” [3].

    Color – Caste – Denomination

    Color – Caste – Denomination –
    These – are Time’s Affair –
    Death’s diviner Classifying
    Does not know they are –

    As in sleep – all Hue forgotten –
    Tenets – put behind –
    Death’s large – Democratic fingers
    Rub away the Brand –

    If Circassian – He is careless –
    If He put away
    Chrysalis of Blonde – or Umber –
    Equal Butterfly –

    They emerge from His Obscuring –
    What Death – knows so well –
    Our minuter intuitions –
    Deem unplausible –

    To view Emily Dickinson’s hand-written copy of this poem, please visit the Emily Dickinson Archive.

    Commentary on Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination”

    The speaker in Emily Dickinson’s “Color – Caste – Denomination” is demonstrating the futility of humanity’s self-classification that is still today widely and tragically misconstrued and continues to lead to unfortunate struggles and misunderstandings among the peoples of the world.

    First Stanza:  The Delusion of Classification

    Color – Caste – Denomination –
    These – are Time’s Affair –
    Death’s diviner Classifying
    Does not know they are –

    The perspicacious speaker begins with an audacious claim: the human soul possesses no ordinary identities associated with race, class (social status), or religion.  By extension, one would realize that if those common classes are null, so is the classification by sex and/or sexual orientation.

    This speaker perceives that those classifications are merely delusional imaginings, resulting from the mayic realm [4] of the operative pairs of opposites which have their being under time’s sway:  “These – are Time’s Affair.” 

    The fact that these classifications vanish after death demonstrates that they are merely delusive tools, useful only, if useful at all, to the material level of existence.  The soul is “Death’s diviner Classifying,” and Death cannot classify the living.  When Death attempts to classify the soul, it finds that the soul’s purity lacks those limiting qualities that humanity assigns itself.

    Second Stanza:   A Dreamer’s Awareness

    As in sleep – all Hue forgotten –
    Tenets – put behind –
    Death’s large – Democratic fingers
    Rub away the Brand –

    The speaker, desiring to further clarify her claim, then compares “death” to “sleep”—in sleep, the human being forgets his/her race, class, religion, and sex.  These “tenets” are abandoned, and the sleeper, if she dreams, may dream herself a different race, class, religion, or sex, but as long as she dreams those classes will seem to be reality.

    Sleep, like Death, has “large – Democratic fingers” which are capable of erasing the marks of human classifications that circumscribe the individual in ordinary, waking consciousness. The dreamer understands her images and relates to them exactly as she does while awake. 

    Third Stanza:   The Unclassifiable Soul

    If Circassian – He is careless –
    If He put away
    Chrysalis of Blonde – or Umber –
    Equal Butterfly –

    The Circassians [5] comprised a civilization in Diaspora, routed by the Russians and then by the Ottoman Empire. Their classifications would be tenuous at best; thus, their ability to classify themselves would be quite difficult, as many other civilizations have experienced.  Peoples who live in contiguity to conquering peoples have found it difficult to maintain a unified identity; such has also been the lot of the Jewish people [6]. 

    But even the “Circassian” who attempts to identity her classification would find that like a butterfly, whether it be “Blonde – or Umber,” she would still remain “Equal Butterfly.” The speaker is suggesting that the usefulness of names on the material plane can never taint the soul. The soul remains perfectly unclassifiable by mayic limitations. 

    This speaker finds solace in this awareness as do most objective, fair-minded thinkers,  but in 21st century America, those who are financially and emotionally invested in the victimhood concocted through identity politics [7] find such an idea abhorrent, as it leaves them without a favorite issue to exploit for political gain [8].

    Fourth Stanza:  Delusive Limitations of Race, Class, Religion, and Gender

    They emerge from His Obscuring –
    What Death – knows so well –
    Our minuter intuitions –
    Deem unplausible –

    The speaker ultimately is averring through suggestion that each human soul is not “obscured” by any attempt to classify it by the delusive limitations of race, class, religion, or sex.   Death knows this, the speaker again emphasizes. Even the tiniest inference that the human mind makes regarding that futile act of classifying will remain “unplausible.”

    Sources

    [1] Saul Mcleod, PhD.  “Stereotypes In Psychology: Definition & Examples.”  SimplyPsychology.  Updated onJune 16, 2023

    [2] Elizabeth Kolbert. “There’s No Scientific Basis for Race—It’s a Made-Up Label.” National Geographic. The Race Issue.

    [3]  King James Version:   Galatians 3: 28.

    [4]  Paramahansa Yogananda.  “Theory of Maya.”  The Royal Path of Kriya Yoga.  Accessed August 18, 2023.

    [5]   Kipyego Isaac Kipruto.  “Who Are the Circassian People?”  World Atlas.  Accessed May 31, 2026.

    [6] Editors.  “Ancient Jewish History: The Diaspora.” Jewish Virtual Library.  Accessed May 31, 2026.

    [7] David Azerrad, Ph.D.”The Promises and Perils of Identity Politics.” The Heritage Foundation.  January 23, 2019.

    [8] Walter Benn Michaels, Charles W. Mills, Linda Hirshman and Carla Murphy.  “What Is the Left Without Identity Politics?” The Nation.  December 16, 2016.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul should always stand ajar” 

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul should always stand ajar” 

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul should always stand ajar” reveals the speaker’s profound insight regarding spiritual readiness. The poem highlights the necessity of remaining receptive to divine visitations.

    Introduction and Text of “The Soul should always stand ajar”

    The speaker explores the delicate relationship between human consciousness and the divine presence. Spiritual alertness requires continuous vulnerability and an open heart. This focus informs this brief but deep metaphysical lyric.

    The poem consists of two quatrain stanzas that function as a single movement. Dickinson has created here a speaker, utilizes her characteristic short lines and unconventional capitalization to emphasize inner vigilance. This structure mirrors the soul’s quiet anticipation.

    On my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, I have discussed many of the aspects that the speakers in Dickinsonian poetry capture in fleeting moments of cosmic awareness.  The speaker creates a drama of inner hospitality.  It encourages readers to prepare for divine communion.

    The Soul should always stand ajar

    The Soul should always stand ajar
    That if the Heaven inquire
    He will not be obliged to wait
    Or shy of troubling Her

    Depart, before the Host have slid
    The Bolt unto the Door –
    To search for the accomplished Guest,
    Her Visitor, no more –

    Commentary on “The Soul should always stand ajar”

    The poem examines the necessity of keeping the consciousness open to celestial encounters. The speaker is guarding against spiritual inertia.

    First Stanza: The Soul’s Expression

    The Soul should always stand ajar
    That if the Heaven inquire
    He will not be obliged to wait
    Or shy of troubling Her

    The speaker commands the inner being to maintain a state of perpetual openness. Using the architectural metaphor of a door left slightly open, readiness is prioritized. The soul must never bar its entrance.

    Divine grace arrives unexpectedly, requiring immediate hospitality from the seeker. The speaker personifies “Heaven” as an inquiring visitor who seeks entry into human consciousness. Receptivity must be instantaneous and completely unhesitating.

    If the door of consciousness is closed, the divine visitor might easily bypass the individual. Paramahansa Yogananda explains that divine realization requires an active, unceasing inner invitation. Receptivity demands consistent spiritual attunement.

    God does not force entry into an unresponsive or distracted mind. The speaker notes that Heaven might feel “shy of troubling” an unready host. Spiritual passivity creates a barrier to grace.

    On my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, I have discussed the speaker’s preoccupation with the border between the human and divine. The open door represents that threshold. It demands constant, attentive safeguarding.

    This welcoming attitude reflects a deep inner yearning for higher truth. The speaker positions the soul as a waiting servant. Universal consciousness requires an empty, waiting vessel to fill.

    Through quiet musing, the seeker recognizes that divine moments are easily missed. The speaker emphasizes that Heaven will not wait indefinitely for a response. Immediate availability is the supreme virtue.

    The door must remain unlatched despite the distractions of earthly life. The speaker frames this openness as a continuous state of being. True spiritual life demands total, uninterrupted vulnerability.

    Second Stanza: Soul Etiquette

    Depart, before the Host have slid
    The Bolt unto the Door –
    To search for the accomplished Guest,
    Her Visitor, no more –

    The speaker outlines the tragic consequence of a locked inner door. If the human host slides the heavy bolt, the divine visitor departs permanently. Neglect seals the spiritual separation.

    The opportunity for divine communion can be lost through self-absorption. The speaker portrays a single, definitive action of closing the entryway. A bolted door signals a rejection of higher realms.

    Paramahansa Yogananda explains that the subtle voice of the Divine is easily drowned out by worldly noise. Quiet inner readiness preserves the sacred connection. Persistent devotion keeps the channel open.

    Once the visitor departs, he will search for that soul “no more.” The speaker delivers a stern warning about the finality of missed grace. Opportunities for awakening are precious and fleeting.

    The “accomplished Guest” represents the highest realization entering the temple of the body. The speaker uses courtly etiquette to describe this sublime visitation. The soul must respect the divine timing.

    On my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, I have discussed Dickinson’s speakers regarding the value they place on the sudden intrusion of the Infinite. Sliding the bolt represents a failure of trust. Isolation results from spiritual fear.

    Through deep musing on these lines, the reader confronts the urgency of spiritual cultivation. The speaker insists that the host must remain vigilant. Delay brings absolute, lingering spiritual poverty.

    The ultimate tragedy is the permanent withdrawal of the celestial presence. The speaker concludes with an unsettling image of eternal abandonment. Receptivity remains the single defense against darkness.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul’s distinct connection”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul’s distinct connection”

    The speaker in Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul’s distinct connection” reveals that immortality is suddenly disclosed through shock and danger experiences.

    Introduction and Text of “The Soul’s distinct connection”

    The speaker presents “The Soul’s distinct connection” as a compressed American-Innovative lyric exploring spiritual perception. Its short lines and slant rimes create a sudden movement from idea to visionary image. The speaker suggests immortality is not gradual knowledge but a flash of direct awareness.

    The speaker frames immortality as something revealed through sudden crisis rather than gradual understanding. The structure anticipates a metaphysical shock that disrupts ordinary perception.

    The Soul’s distinct connection”

    The Soul’s distinct connection
    With immortality
    Is best disclosed by Danger
    Or quick Calamity –

    As Lightning on a Landscape
    Exhibits Sheets of Place –
    Not yet suspected – but for Flash –
    And Click – and Suddenness.

    Commentary on “The Soul’s distinct connection”

    The speaker frames immortality as something revealed through sudden crisis rather than gradual understanding. The structure anticipates a metaphysical shock that disrupts ordinary perception.  Her vision aligns with Paramahansa Yogananda’s teaching that immortality is perceived through sudden inner awakening beyond ordinary awareness.

    First Stanza: The Soul and Immortality

    The Soul’s distinct connection
    With immortality
    Is best disclosed by Danger
    Or quick Calamity –

    In the first stanza, the speaker defines a direct relationship between the soul and immortality, presenting the connection as inherent rather than acquired, embedded within the very structure of consciousness itself. This connection is not continuously visible in ordinary perception, but it becomes evident when danger or sudden calamity interrupts the expected flow of life and thought. 

    Paramahansa Yogananda explains that the soul perceives immortality most clearly when the mind is startled into higher awareness beyond sensory routine, allowing intuitive consciousness to rise above temporal limitation enabling perception of immortality as immediate experience rather than abstract belief grounded in time-bound reasoning.

    In the phrase “Danger / Or quick Calamity,” the speaker emphasizes the disruptive force required to awaken spiritual perception, suggesting that only extreme interruption can break habitual mental patterns. 

    On my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, I have discussed the fact that Dickinson often uses shock imagery to reveal hidden spiritual states, where disruption becomes a gateway to deeper awareness of the soul. 

    Here the speaker suggests that spiritual awareness emerges when normal continuity is broken, forcing consciousness into a heightened state of perception that resembles awakening from illusion aligning consciousness with a sudden intuitive shift beyond habitual cognition.

    Second Stanza: Soul Suddenness

    As Lightning on a Landscape
    Exhibits Sheets of Place –
    Not yet suspected – but for Flash –
    And Click – and Suddenness.

    In the second stanza, the speaker uses lightning as the central image to describe how spiritual perception suddenly reveals the hidden structure of reality, revealing perception as a sudden cognitive rupture rather than a gradual interpretive process unfolding in time. 

    This revelation is not gradual but instantaneous, exposing “Sheets of Place” across the landscape of experience implying hidden dimensionality within ordinary perception itself. 

    Paramahansa Yogananda explains that divine insight often arrives like a flash of lightning, dissolving mental obscurity and awakening superconscious awareness where consciousness transcends linear reasoning and enters intuitive cognition.

    The speaker suggests that reality is composed of layers that are normally invisible, only becoming apparent when perception is abruptly illuminated suggesting that ordinary awareness conceals deeper structures until disrupted by sudden insight. 

    On my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, I have noted that Dickinson compresses vast metaphysical ideas into brief, electric imagery that mimics sudden spiritual awakening where brevity intensifies metaphysical meaning through concentrated symbolic expression that emphasizes non-linear cognition characteristic of mystical experience. 

    This structure mirrors mystical experience, where understanding arrives all at once rather than through linear reasoning reinforcing the immediacy of perception as a sudden cognitive awakening beyond temporal sequence, dissolving fragmentation into unified awareness that transcends sensory division aligning sensory faculties into a single integrated perception of truth.

    The imagery of flash and click emphasizes immediacy, suggesting a sudden recognition of truth that cannot be delayed or extended over time emphasizing that spiritual understanding arrives as a decisive moment rather than gradual accumulation. 

    Paramahansa Yogananda explains that when consciousness rises above sensory limitation, truth is perceived as a single unified moment of clarity marking transformation from illusion to awakened recognition within consciousness. 

    The speaker frames this experience as both visual and auditory, merging perception into one unified spiritual event where poetic compression mirrors expanded metaphysical insight through condensed language.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul unto itself”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul unto itself”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul unto itself” dramatizes the mysterious power of the individual soul to function either as humanity’s greatest ally or its fiercest betrayer.

    Introduction and Text of “The Soul unto itself”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul unto itself” features the poet’s characteristic minimalist style, employing brief lines, slant rime, and startling metaphysical assertions. The speaker contemplates the dual nature of the soul.

    She recognizes that the inner self may serve as a majestic companion or as a painful source of suffering.  The poem’s two quatrains move from the soul’s conflicting capacities to its ultimate sovereignty. 

    The first stanza reveals the soul’s ability either to comfort or torment itself, while the second stanza advances the spiritual truth that the soul ultimately answers only to its own Divine Authority.

    As discussed in earlier commentaries on Dickinson poems at my literary website Linda’s Literary Home, Dickinson’s speakers often muse upon mystical realities that transcend material existence. 

    The poet’s speakers repeatedly suggest an intuitive understanding of spiritual truths resembling teachings articulated by Paramahansa Yogananda, who explains that “Self-realization is the knowing—in body, mind, and soul—that we are one with the omnipresence of God.”

    The Soul unto itself

    The Soul unto itself
    Is an imperial friend –
    Or the most agonizing Spy –
    An Enemy – could send –

    Secure against its own –
    No treason it can fear –
    Itself – its Sovereign – of itself
    The Soul should stand in Awe –

    Commentary on “The Soul unto itself”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul unto itself” portrays the soul as both ruler and witness, capable of elevating or devastating human consciousness.

    First Stanza: The Soul’s Friend

    The Soul unto itself
    Is an imperial friend –
    Or the most agonizing Spy –
    An Enemy – could send –

    The speaker immediately asserts that the soul possesses immense authority and influence over human experience. By describing the soul as “an imperial friend,” the speaker assigns regal stature to the inner self, suggesting majesty, dignity, and unwavering companionship.

    The term “imperial” enlarges the soul’s status beyond ordinary friendship. The speaker implies that no worldly companion can equal the soul’s intimate knowledge of the individual mind and heart.

    Yet the speaker quickly pivots from comfort to anguish. The same soul capable of friendship may also become “the most agonizing Spy,” a phrase that transforms inward awareness into relentless surveillance.

    A spy observes secretly and reports faithfully, and thus the speaker recognizes that conscience cannot be deceived. Human beings may conceal motives from society, but the soul witnesses every thought, emotion, and action.

    The speaker’s characterization is similar to Paramahansa Yogananda’s teaching that “The soul is the silent witness.” The Dickinsonian speaker appears keenly aware that the inward self silently records all human conduct, whether noble or shameful.

    The phrase “An Enemy – could send –” intensifies the drama by implying that no external foe can equal the suffering generated by one’s own disturbed consciousness. External enemies may wound the body or reputation, but the troubled soul torments continually from within.

    The speaker therefore presents the soul as the central determining force in human life. Peace or misery originates not primarily from outer conditions but from the soul’s relationship with itself.

    Such musing parallels observations from my discussions of Dickinson’s mystical intuition atmy literary website,Linda’s Literary Home, where Dickinson’s speakers repeatedly probe the unseen dimensions of consciousness. The speaker of this poem demonstrates that same fascination with the hidden operations of the interior life.

    This stanza also reveals Dickinson’s remarkable compression or minimalism. In only four lines, the speaker constructs a complete psychological and spiritual drama in which the soul occupies simultaneously the positions of monarch, companion, observer, and adversary.

    Second Stanza: Soul Power

    Secure against its own –
    No treason it can fear –
    Itself – its Sovereign – of itself
    The Soul should stand in Awe –

    In the second stanza, the speaker shifts from conflict to authority. Once the soul recognizes its own sovereignty, it becomes “Secure against its own,” because genuine spiritual realization eliminates inner division.

    The speaker then declares that the soul can fear “No treason.” Treason signifies betrayal against rightful authority, yet nothing external can overthrow the soul that understands its divine origin and independence.

    The speaker’s declaration echoes Paramahansa Yogananda’s insistence that individuals should not identify merely with the physical body or passing emotions. The great Guru teaches, “Do not think of yourself as the body, but as the joyous consciousness and immortal life behind it.” Dickinson’s speaker likewise urges recognition of the soul’s immortal stature.

    The line “Itself – its Sovereign – of itself” offers one of Dickinson’s most concentrated statements regarding spiritual selfhood. The soul governs itself because its deepest authority derives from divine reality rather than from external institutions or social systems.

    The speaker therefore suggests that authentic strength emerges inwardly. Human beings often surrender their peace to public opinion, material hardship, or emotional instability, but the soul possesses a higher center of authority beyond those fleeting disturbances.

    The poem’s final assertion that “The Soul should stand in Awe –” reveals profound reverence for the mystery of consciousness itself. The speaker does not advocate pride or egoism; instead, she recognizes the sacred dimension of the soul.

    That reverential tone harmonizes with Paramahansa Yogananda’s teaching that the soul reflects divine consciousness. He explains, “The universal everything is made of the singular consciousness of God. When a spark of that consciousness is individualized by God, it becomes a soul.” Dickinson’s speaker appears intuitively aware of that same sublime truth.

    The final line leaves the reader contemplating the grandeur hidden within individual consciousness. The soul becomes simultaneously observer, ruler, and sacred presence, worthy not of fear alone but of awe.

    As in many Dickinson poems, the speaker transforms a brief lyric into a profound spiritual riddle. Beneath the compressed language lies a vast contemplative musing on selfhood, divine authority, and the mysterious power residing within every human soul.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul that hath a Guest”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul that hath a Guest”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul that hath a Guest” dramatizes the soul’s complete fulfillment after welcoming the Divine Presence within consciousness.

    Introduction and Text of “The Soul that hath a Guest”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul that hath a Guest” features a speaker contemplating the disposition of a soul that has become inwardly united with the Divine Reality. The compressed little lyric contains only two quatrain stanzas, yet the speaker manages to suggest an entire metaphysical philosophy regarding the soul’s preference for spiritual companionship over worldly diversion.

    The poem advances through two balanced, harmonious movements. The first quatrain establishes the soul’s contentment in remaining inwardly absorbed because of the “Diviner Crowd” dwelling within. The second quatrain stanza reveals that spiritual courtesy itself forbids abandoning one’s inward sanctuary while entertaining “The Emperor of Men.”

    This Dickinsonian drama recalls the teachings of the “Father of Yoga in the West” Paramahansa Yogananda, who often taught that communion with the Divine becomes so absorbing that worldly restlessness naturally diminishes. Dickinson’s speaker reveals the same intuition regarding the soul’s preference for inner bliss over outward entertainment.

    The Soul that hath a Guest

    The Soul that hath a Guest 

    Doth seldom go abroad –
    Diviner Crowd at Home –
    Obliterate the need –

    And Courtesy forbid
    A Host’s departure when
    Upon Himself be visiting
    The Emperor of Men –

    Commentary on “The Soul that hath a Guest”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul that hath a Guest” portrays the soul’s inward fulfillment after receiving the companionship of the Divine Belovèd.

    First Stanza: God and Solitude

    The Soul that hath a Guest
    Doth seldom go abroad –
    Diviner Crowd at Home –
    Obliterate the need –

    The speaker begins with the remarkable assertion that the soul possessing “a Guest” no longer feels compelled to “go abroad.” The term “abroad” suggests worldly involvement, social distraction, and outward seeking among transient pleasures that can never permanently satisfy the human heart. The soul’s newfound inward richness renders external wandering increasingly unnecessary.

    The identity of the “Guest” gradually emerges through implication rather than direct declaration. Dickinson’s speakers often employ riddling language that hints rather than explains.

    And here the speaker permits the reader to infer that the “Guest” is none other than God or Divine Consciousness Itself. The presence of the “Diviner Crowd at Home” confirms that the soul has become inhabited by spiritual reality greater than ordinary earthly companionship.

    The phrase “Diviner Crowd” possesses a curious and mystical resonance because the speaker refers to a singular “Guest” but then transforms that singularity into a “Crowd.” Such language suggests the infinite qualities of Spirit that accompany divine communion: peace, joy, wisdom, harmony, and intuitive understanding. One divine Presence contains more richness than the multitude of worldly associations.

    The speaker then explains that the “Diviner Crowd” can “Obliterate the need.” The verb “obliterate” demonstrates the completeness of spiritual fulfillment because the soul no longer merely suppresses worldly cravings; instead, those cravings dissolve altogether in the greater attraction of divine companionship.

    The speaker understands that spiritual realization does not operate through deprivation but through replacement of lesser satisfactions with greater bliss.  Paramahansa Yogananda frequently emphasized that the soul’s true happiness arises from inward communion with God rather than dependence upon external entertainments. 

    Paramahansa Yogananda teaches, “When you know God as peace within, you will realize Him as peace existing in the universal harmony of all things without.” Dickinson’s speaker reveals that same calm inward certainty resulting from spiritual companionship.

    The speaker’s little drama also focuses on the same theme that Dickinson explores often because of her fascination with the soul’s hidden life.   Her speakers repeatedly suggest that external society pales beside the soul’s own immense inward kingdom. This speaker likewise demonstrates that once the soul discovers the Divine Reality, ordinary worldly movement loses much of its fascination.

    Second Stanza:  God and Hospitality

    And Courtesy forbid
    A Host’s departure when
    Upon Himself be visiting
    The Emperor of Men –

    The second stanza deepens the speaker’s conceit by employing the metaphor of hospitality. The soul now becomes a “Host,” while the divine Presence remains the honored “Guest.” Because the soul is entertaining such exalted company, ordinary “Courtesy” itself forbids departure from the inward sanctuary.

    The speaker’s use of “Courtesy” lends a delicate social elegance to the spiritual circumstance. Even in worldly etiquette, a gracious host would never abandon an honored visitor. Thus, the soul absorbed in divine awareness naturally remains inwardly attentive because no earthly obligation could surpass the importance of entertaining “The Emperor of Men.”

    The final phrase majestically identifies the Guest’s true stature. The “Emperor of Men” clearly symbolizes God as sovereign over all humanity and creation itself. The speaker therefore implies that once divine consciousness enters the soul’s awareness, all lesser attractions become secondary beside the majesty of that Presence.

    Dickinson’s speaker carefully avoids theological dogma while still conveying unmistakable spiritual intimacy. The poem remains experiential rather than doctrinal because the speaker focuses not upon religious systems but upon the soul’s transformed condition after inwardly realizing divine companionship. Such subtlety allows the poem to retain both mystical suggestiveness and artistic restraint.

    Paramahansa Yogananda similarly taught that the soul discovers its deepest fulfillment through interior communion with God. Paramahansa Yogananda explains, “The more you appreciate the divine image in everyone, the more you are alive with God’s consciousness.” 

    Dickinson’s speaker reveals a consciousness already so absorbed in the divine realm that outward movement appears unnecessary in comparison to the bliss of inward companionship.

    The speaker’s reverent inwardness also recalls Paramahansa Yogananda’s frequent emphasis on stillness and soul awareness. Divine realization requires inward receptivity, not ceaseless outward motion. Dickinson’s speaker therefore dramatizes the soul quietly remaining at home because the greatest conceivable Guest already dwells within.

  • Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul has Bandaged moments”

    Image: Emily Dickinson - Amherst College - Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 - likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet
    Image: Emily Dickinson – Amherst College – Daguerrotype of the poet at age 17, circa 1847 – likely the only authentic, extant likeness of the poet

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul has Bandaged moments”

    The speaker in Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul has Bandaged moments” presents a musing on terror, ecstasy, and spiritual oscillation within the human psyche.  For these states of consciousness, it is perhaps more accurate to use the term “psyche” instead of soul, thereby interpreting “Soul” as a metaphor for “psyche.”

    Introduction and Text of “The Soul has Bandaged moments”

    Emily Dickinson’s “The Soul has Bandaged moments” dramatizes the alternating states of fear, violation, liberation, and re-captivity that define the soul’s earthly experience. The speaker renders these states through stark, virtually violent imagery, suggesting that inner life is neither placid nor consistently enlightened but subject to extremes that test spiritual endurance.

    The poem plays out in mostly irregular stanzas, each marking a shift in the soul’s condition, from paralysis to assault, from escape to recapture. The speaker’s vision resonates with Paramahansa Yogananda’s teaching that the soul, though divine, becomes “identified with the body and mind,” thereby experiencing alternating bondage and freedom.

    Because the soul is perfect as a spark of God in the human being, it may be more accurate to think of the entity in this poem as the human psyche, instead of the soul, as the psyche is an inferior reflection of that divine Spirit.

    The Soul has Bandaged moments

    The Soul has Bandaged moments –
    When too appalled to stir –
    She feels some ghastly Fright come up
    And stop to look at her –

    Salute her – with long fingers –
    Caress her freezing hair –
    Sip, Goblin, from the very lips
    The Lover – hovered – o’er –
    Unworthy, that a thought so mean
    Accost a Theme – so – fair –

    The soul has moments of Escape –
    When bursting all the doors –
    She dances like a Bomb, abroad,
    And swings upon the Hours,

    As do the Bee – delirious borne –
    Long Dungeoned from his Rose –
    Touch Liberty – then know no more,
    But Noon, and Paradise –

    The Soul’s retaken moments –
    When, Felon led along,
    With shackles on the plumed feet,
    And staples, in the Song,

    The Horror welcomes her, again,
    These, are not brayed of Tongue –

    Commentary on “The Soul has Bandaged moments”

    This poem focuses on a portrayal of the human psyche’s oscillation between bondage and transcendence, rendered through visceral psychological and spiritual imagery.  The psyche is an interior reflection of the soul, or the soul’s shadow.  It is important to remember that the soul remains perfect and untouched by all human experience, even as the mind (or psyche) does undergo those experiences. 

    First Stanza: Perceived Fright

    The Soul has Bandaged moments –
    When too appalled to stir –
    She feels some ghastly Fright come up
    And stop to look at her –

    The speaker introduces a soul immobilized, “bandaged” not physically but psychologically, suggesting wounds that inhibit motion and will. This paralysis arises from an unnamed “ghastly Fright,” an entity that is less defined than felt, emphasizing the internal origin of terror.

    The fright’s act of stopping “to look at her” reverses the expected dynamic, placing the soul under scrutiny rather than in observation. Such inversion intensifies vulnerability, as the soul becomes the object of an invasive awareness it cannot evade.

    Paramahansa Yogananda teaches that fear arises when consciousness forgets its divine source and identifies with limitation, a condition that leaves the soul susceptible to imagined horrors. The speaker’s depiction aligns with this notion, as the fright appears less an external demon than a manifestation of estranged awareness.

    Second Stanza: The Value of Experience

    Salute her – with long fingers –
    Caress her freezing hair –
    Sip, Goblin, from the very lips
    The Lover – hovered – o’er –
    Unworthy, that a thought so mean
    Accost a Theme – so – fair –

    The second stanza intensifies the violation, as the fright transforms into a grotesque intimacy that mocks tenderness. The “long fingers” and “freezing hair” suggest a parody of affection, where what should comfort instead invades and chills.

    The image of the “Goblin” sipping from lips once sanctified by a “Lover” dramatizes desecration, implying that sacred experience can be corrupted by lower consciousness. The speaker recoils at the indignity, declaring such intrusion “unworthy” of the soul’s inherent fairness.

    In earlier reflections at my literary website, Linda’s Literary Home, the soul’s purity is often described as inviolable despite worldly distortions, a distinction the present speaker struggles to maintain. The stanza underscores that experience, even when degrading, forces recognition of contrast between the soul’s divine origin and its earthly entanglements.

    Third Stanza: Severed Elation

    The soul has moments of Escape –
    When bursting all the doors –
    She dances like a Bomb, abroad,
    And swings upon the Hours,

    The tone shifts abruptly as the soul achieves explosive liberation, “bursting all the doors” that previously confined it. The simile “like a Bomb” conveys both violence and exhilaration, suggesting that freedom arrives not gently but through rupture.

    The soul’s movement “upon the Hours” indicates transcendence of temporal limitation, as if time itself becomes a medium for play rather than constraint. Such imagery evokes ecstatic states in which consciousness expands beyond ordinary bounds.

    Paramahansa Yogananda often describes spiritual awakening as a sudden expansion into joy, where the devotee feels unbound by material restrictions. The speaker captures this surge, yet its intensity hints at instability, as what erupts so forcefully may not sustain itself.

    Fourth Stanza: Subtle Escape

    As do the Bee – delirious borne –
    Long Dungeoned from his Rose –
    Touch Liberty – then know no more,
    But Noon, and Paradise –

    The speaker refines the image of escape through the metaphor of a bee released from confinement, emphasizing natural joy rather than explosive force. The bee, once “dungeoned,” now experiences liberty as immersion in “Noon, and Paradise,” suggesting fullness and illumination.

    This state implies a loss of self-consciousness, where the soul, like the bee, ceases to analyze and simply exists within bliss. The word “delirious” conveys both intoxication and transcendence, a condition beyond rational articulation.

    Paramahansa Yogananda’s teachings describe divine communion as a state where the devotee “forgets the body in joy,” an idea reflected in the bee’s total absorption. The speaker thus presents a more harmonious form of freedom, one aligned with the soul’s natural affinity for the divine.

    Fifth Stanza: A Cacophony of Plight

    The Soul’s retaken moments –
    When, Felon led along,
    With shackles on the plumed feet,
    And staples, in the Song,

    The return to bondage is rendered with judicial severity, as the soul becomes a “Felon” led in chains, suggesting condemnation rather than mere relapse. The “plumed feet” evoke former freedom, now mocked by shackles that deny their natural function.

    The phrase “staples, in the Song” implies that even expression becomes constrained, as if the soul’s voice is fastened and distorted. This image captures the frustration of remembering freedom while being unable to reclaim it.

    In my prior commentary on other pages of this site, Linda’s Literary Home, I have suggested that such reversals often reveal the cyclical nature of the spiritual struggle, where insight does not guarantee permanence. The speaker underscores that the soul’s plight includes not only suffering but the memory of lost transcendence.

    Sixth Stanza: The Unspeakable Ineffable

    The Horror welcomes her, again,
    These, are not brayed of Tongue –

    The final lines close with a return to horror, now familiar enough to “welcome” the soul, suggesting a grim cycle rather than a singular event. The recurrence implies that such states are integral to the soul’s earthly passage.

    The assertion that these experiences “are not brayed of Tongue” emphasizes their ineffability, resisting articulation despite their intensity. Language fails where inner extremity begins, leaving only suggestive imagery.

    Paramahansa Yogananda notes that the deepest spiritual and psychological experiences 

    transcend verbal expression, accessible only through direct realization. The speaker concludes within that silence, where terror and transcendence alike elude the limits of speech.