Linda's Literary Home

John Keats’ “In drear-nighted December”

Portrait of John Keats by William Hilton the Younger (1786–1839) https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poets/john-keats Poetry Foundation
Image: Portrait of John Keats by William Hilton the Younger (1786–1839) – Poetry Foundation

John Keats’ “In drear-nighted December”

John Keats’ poem, “In drear nighted December,” dramatizes the constancy of things in nature—a tree and a brook—while showing how different the human heart behaves.  The behavior of those natural elements becomes a Romantic symbol for human beings to cognize their inner divinity.

Introduction and Text of “In drear-nighted December”

In John Keats’ “In drear-nighted December,” the speaker first addresses a tree and a brook, and then he becomes quite philosophical as he reflects on human experience; he then offers a musing on resilience, memory, and human suffering through loss.

Each of the three stanzas in Keats’ “In drear-nighted December” consists of eight lines; the rime scheme is unique and must be reckoned over the entire poem to appreciate the technical skill employed: ABABCCCD AEACFFFD GHGHIIID.

The reader will note that the final words in each stanza rime—prime, time, rime (rhyme), an unusual touch that enhances the mood of the poem by unifying its suggestions. The rhythm also contributes to the melancholy of the poem.

In drear nighted December

In drear nighted December,
   Too happy, happy tree,
Thy branches ne’er remember
   Their green felicity—
The north cannot undo them
With a sleety whistle through them
Nor frozen thawings glue them
   From budding at the prime.

In drear-nighted December,
   Too happy, happy brook,
Thy bubblings ne’er remember
   Apollo’s summer look;
But with a sweet forgetting,
They stay their crystal fretting,
Never, never petting
   About the frozen time.

Ah! would ‘twere so with many
   A gentle girl and boy—
But were there ever any
   Writh’d not of passed joy?
The feel of not to feel it,
When there is none to heal it
Nor numbed sense to steel it,
   Was never said in rime.

Commentary on “In drear-nighted December”

The first two stanzas of this poem commits the pathetic fallacy.  In the hands of less skillful poets or poetasters, the pathetic fallacy sounds silly and imparts no true meaning.

However, when poets of the caliber of Keats employs that fallacy, such indulgence may not only be accepted but understood that the poet has skillfully imparted meaning in useful and beautiful manner.

First Stanza:  Musing on a Tree’s Memory

The speaker begins by addressing a “Too happy, happy tree.” The excited phrase readily creates a tone of possible envy, through employment of the pathetic fallacy, which relies on anthropomorphism. The repetition of “happy” suggests excessive joy, as if the tree’s contentment surpasses what the speaker is capable of indulging.

The speaker muses on the tree’s memory, claiming that it does not recall the green days of summer when its branches were rife with green leaves. This claim is telling: it reveals the speaker’s human penchant for  foisting memory and nostalgia onto natural entities.

The speaker makes such claims even as he also surmises that nature operates on a different level of sentience from that of human beings.  The image of “green felicity” is particularly striking, as it cognizes lush foliage as the paragon of the tree’s happiness.

The scions of the tree’s branches, full of leaves, symbolize a state of natural bliss, unhampered by the blight of recollection.  The speaker opines that the absence of leaves in winter might steal from the tree it happiness, but he immediately counters and changes his mind about that idea.

The empty branches, unburdened by the “bitterness of winter,” lose no value in their possibility. The speaker avers that the cold “north cannot undo them,” and the ice that weights down the branches cannot diminish their potential for creativity.

The power of resilience centers itself into the stanza’s thesis: the tree’s happiness does not depend upon externals, such as an abundance of leaves.  Such is but is an intrinsic quality, renewing each spring on the budding branches.

Many of the Romantic ideals are represented in the imagery in “In drear-nighted December” and parallel the sentiment found in other poems by Keats, such as “Sonnet VII O Solitude! if I must with thee dwell“ and “Sonnet XI On first looking into Chapman’s Homer.”

The tree’s unfailing skill in regenerating, thus creating a “happy greenness of leaves” in spite of winter’s harshness, emphasizes the theme of renewal that is infused into the stanza. The speaker is amazed by the tree’s obvious indifference to loss, a quality that foreshadows the poem’s later musing on human fragility.

The stanza also offers a gentle criticism of human misapprehension about happiness. By anthropomorphizing the tree, the speaker opens up a paradox: while humans align happiness with certain conditions, such as summer’s fecundity, the tree’s joy comes through transcending such events.

Second Stanza:   Musing on a Brook’s Memory

The second stanza pivots to a frozen brook, continuing the speaker’s musing on a natural object. As the tree was, so the brook is described as a “happy, happy brook,” echoing the excited tone of the first stanza.

The speaker makes his claim again, as with the tree, that the brook does not recall its summer felicity, at time during which it flowed freely and babbled full of life.

This forgetfulness is styled a virtue, permitting the brook to continue its “bubblings” even through winter’s ice, without succumbing to lamentation of the “frozen time.”

The brook’s persistence becomes a symbol for resilience. Its continued babbling beneath the hard, cold ice suggests a quiet, uncomplaining acceptance, as well as a refusal to be silenced by external conditions.

The speaker interprets this persistence as happiness, again committing to the act of anthropomorphism to project human values onto the brook’s natural process.   However, unlike human beings, who complain about their hardships, the brook “never complains” but instead continues its natural vocation—flowing on, without disrupting its environment with melancholy.

This stanza’s anthropomorphism mirrors the first stanza but brings on a dynamic element: while the tree’s happiness is dependent upon cyclical renewal, the brook’s felicity is expressed through tireless motion, even in adverse conditions.  The imagery of the frozen brook invokes a sense of unseen vitality, a divine life force must persist beneath the surface.

This divine suggestion parallels  Romantic depictions of nature as a source of eternal renewal, as seen in Wordsworth’s “It is a beauteous evening, calm and free,” a poem that exemplifies the classic Romantic theme of infusing earthly loveliness and innocence with the Divine.  

The brook’s indifference to its frozen condition parallels the tree’s indifference to winter’s bleak lifelessness, further supporting the poem’s theme of nature’s resilience.

The speaker’s admiration for this quality heralds a growing tension: nature’s ability to endure without complaint contrasts sharply with human responses to loss, a theme that will be fully probed in the final stanza.

The stanza also subtly critiques human perception. By interpreting the brook’s persistence as happiness, the speaker reveals a tendency to romanticize nature, projecting human emotions onto processes that remain indifferent.

This anthropomorphism, pathetic fallacy, sets up a philosophical question: is nature truly “happy,” or is this a human construct imposed on a neutral world?

The stanza leaves this question unanswered, allowing the reader to ponder the nature of happiness itself.

And although such question can never be satisfactorily answered, the human mind remains capable of thinking about and musing on any number of questions that cannot be answered, logically, scientifically, or philosophically.

Third Stanza:   Musing on the Philosophy of Possibility

The third stanza then shifts from observation to philosophical introspection, as the speaker applies the situations of the tree and brook to the human condition. The stanza begins with a philosophical musing on the “possibility” of humans emulating the resilience of nature in the face of melancholy and loss.

This pivot inward remains quintessentially Romantic, calling forth Keats’s musings on mortality and transience in poems such as “Ode on a Grecian Urn.” The speaker wonders whether humans can confront their “melancholy times” with the same even-mindedness as the tree and brook, suggesting that such equanimity remains rare.

Through a rhetorical question, the speaker implies that humans typically “writhe” when their joy passes them by, a vivid verb that conveys anguish and resistance. Unlike the tree, which accepts winter’s barrenness, or the brook, which flows beneath the ice, humans struggle against loss, unable to let go of what was.  

This stark contrast emphasizes a central tension in the poem: nature’s cyclical resilience versus humanity’s linear experience of time, where loss feels permanent and irreparable.

The speaker then proffers the strange and inaccurate claim that poetry has not been composed on the issue of how it feels “To know the change and feel it, / When there is none to heal it, / Nor numbed sense to steal it.”

The speaker, no doubt, is suggesting that no solution to the problem is commonly noted, that there is no earthly , material remedy for the loss of “passed joy.” But, of course, poetry is filled with melancholic ponderings of such sadness.

Thus alternatively, the bizarre claim may be understood to suggest that the specific experience of feeling loss without hope of resolution has been under-explored, a nuanced perspective that aligns with Keats’s fascination with the coexistence of joy and sorrow.

The stanza’s philosophical depth lies in its exploration of human vulnerability. The speaker acknowledges that while no earthly remedy exists for the loss of “passed joy,” a sentiment remains salient that echoes Keats’ notion that melancholy dwells alongside beauty.

The tree and brook, unburdened by memory or anticipation, offer a model of resilience that humans struggle to emulate. Yet the speaker’s reflection is not entirely pessimistic; by posing the possibility of learning from nature, he invites readers to consider whether such resilience is attainable, even if it is difficult.

Comments

Questions, comments, suggestions offered in good faith are always welcome. If you use a pseudonym, please include your real name, if you expect a response.